Study Concludes That Hands-Free Devices are not a Magic Solution for Distracted Driving

Manufacturers of hands-free and voice-activated devices claim that their products allow drivers to send and check emails and texts while still keeping their eyes focused on the road and their hands on the wheel. Many drivers assume that these devices are safer and are a good way to prevent distracted driving in Homestead or their communities.

A new AAA study casts doubt on these assumptions.

According to the study, voice-activated, hands-free devices can still be very distracting for drivers – especially if the devices fail to recognize the speaker’s voice and the driver has to repeat what they are saying. The study looked at drivers using devices that relied on voice command or hands-free features to allow drivers to place calls, change the car’s entertainment system, or text messages. Drivers were placed in simulators and asked to use the hands-free devices while having to “drive” through a course.

driving distracted

Most of the drivers remained distracted. One driver in the simulator got so distracted using Facebook and the hands-free device that she caused a rear-end collision. Researchers concluded that the 167 drivers in the study showed heightened levels of distraction and slowed reaction times when they used voice-command hands-free systems to change radio stations, make phone calls, and perform other basic tasks. Some drivers missed cues placed on the simulated road and others responded slowly to the cues meant to check their level of attentiveness.

Not all Hands-Free Devices are the Same

The study also ranked different hands-free devices manufacturers installed in cars. The devices were ranked according to how often they got prompts wrong and how distracting they were to use. Researchers rated Toyota’s Entune system as best and GM’s MyLink system as worst. According to researchers, drivers fared worse with more complicated systems and systems that required multiple commands or multiple corrections.

Although the study did not say that using the hands-free devices would lead to car accidents, researchers did establish that the devices still cause a significant level of distraction for drivers. The study in fact supports earlier discussions of distraction, which defined distracted driving as any activity that removes the motorist’s eyes from the road, their hands from the wheel, or their mind from driving. While the devices allow the driver to keep their eyes on the road and their hands off the wheel, they may be distracting enough to cause a driver to miss important cues.

The Future of Distracted Driving and Hands-Free Devices

It is likely that further studies will be done to determine the role that hands-free devices play in distracted driving. It is also possible that manufacturers will continue to develop their voice command features and improve their accuracy so that they are less distracting.

Have you been injured due to a mechanical failure in your car or due to a distracted driver in Homestead or your community? The law firm of Flaxman Law Group is fully dedicated to helping those injured in car accidents secure compensation and justice for their injuries. To discuss your injuries with a compassionate and professional legal team, contact Flaxman Law Group at any time to schedule a free, no obligation case review.

Client Reviews
Mr. Flaxman is highly skilled and very pleasant to work with. He communicated with me at every step in the process, and clearly presented information relating to my case. To anyone considering retaining his firm, I highly recommend him. Clara Barman
THE BEST. Honest, very knowledgeable, fast and easy. has helped me in numerous situations and has never failed me. Joe Gee
Charlie is a very skilled attorney that advocates hard for his clients. But the best part is he is an all around great guy. He cares about helping and doing what is right for people and his community. And he is not afraid to fight against those who do wrong or against threats to our world. He is fluent in Spanish as well. Do yourself a favor and call him. Andy
I had a lawyer on another case and I never spoke to the lawyer and I hated that I never knew what was going on in my case. Mr. Flaxman was in constant communication with me, explained everything to me, and his staff was really great too. My phone calls were always returned immediately. It was refreshing to be able to speak to my attorney personally. I would HIGHLY recommend Mr. Flaxman as an attorney to anyone who has been in an accident. Gloria
I found Mr. Flaxman to be an excellent attorney for my personal injury case. This is actually the second time I have used him and he really represented my interests. He explained everything thoroughly and he was very available for my questions. Carol
Contact Information